The Patent Shoppe
  • Home
  • Firm Information
    • Areas of Practice
    • Firm Philosophy
    • Services and Pricing
  • Personnel
    • Patrick J. Lavender
  • Insight
  • Links
  • Contact Us

What is the legal standard employed to determine equivalence?

4/26/2017

 
The legal test is whether the allegedly infringing device performs "substantially the same function in substantially the same way to obtain the same result."  See, e.g., Malta v. Schulmerich Carillons, Inc. 952 F.2d 1320, 1327 (Fed. Cir. 1991). How easy is it for a court to determine this?

As far back in 1818, Justice Story on the U.S. Supreme Court commented that:

"In all my experience I can scarcely recollect a single instance, in which the general question, whether the principles of two machines were the same or different, has not produced from different witnesses, equally credible and equally intelligent, opposite answers." Barrett v. Hall, 2 F. Cas. 914, 923 (C.C.D. Mass. 1818).

Comments are closed.

    Insight
    ( Official Blog )

    RSS Feed

© COPYRIGHT 2015, THE PATENT SHOPPE. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. THIS WEBSITE IS PUBLISHED BY THE LAW FIRM THE PATENT SHOPPE. ITS CONTENTS ARE NOT INTENDED TO SERVE AS LEGAL ADVICE OR LEGAL OPINION. SUCH ADVICE MAY ONLY BE PROVIDED WHEN RELATED TO SPECIFIC FACT SITUATIONS THAT THE PATENT SHOPPE HAS BEEN RETAINED AS COUNSEL TO ADDRESS.